Students missing out on vital career/life planning support
March 01, 2017
New report reveals gaps & overlap in provincial policy
The majority of elementary schools and nearly half of high schools have been unable to implement the province’s education, career and life-planning program.
People for Education’s report – Career and life planning in Ontario’s Schools: Multiple paths; multiple policies; multiple challenges – points to a number of challenges, including a lack of guidance counsellors, insufficient support and training, and the impact of multiple initiatives.
Schools unable to implement mandatory aspects of policy
Ontario’s careers policy, Creating Pathways to Success, includes a number of mandatory components, including career and life-planning committees in every school, portfolios for every student from kindergarten to grade 12, and professional development for teachers. But of the mandatory components in the policy, the report shows that:
- Only 15% of elementary and 39% of secondary schools have career and life planning committees.
- In 34% of kindergarten to grade 6, and 56% of secondary schools, all students have education and career/life planning portfolios.
- 23% of elementary and 40% of secondary schools report professional development on career and life planning is available to their teachers.
Guidance counsellors required
Data from the Ontario School Survey show that only elementary schools with grades 7 and 8 (where students must choose their high school courses) have had success in implementing career/life planning portfolios. But even in those schools, principals point to the difficulty of implementing the program without guidance counsellors. Only 23% of schools with grades 7 and 8 have guidance counsellors, and most are part time.
In high schools – where guidance counsellors provide key support for education, career and life planning – the ratio of students to guidance counsellors averages 380 to 1. In some schools it is as high as 600 to 1.
“We really need additional funding to have guidance counselors available at the elementary level to facilitate proper life planning and transition to high school.”
Principal, elementary school, Hamilton-Wentworth School Board
Recommendations for change
“The pace of change is speeding up. Nearly one-third of today’s school children will go on to be employed in occupations that don’t currently exist when they graduate from high school,” says Bruce Lawson, President of The Counselling Foundation of Canada. “It is vital that society – and our schools – equip our future generations with the skills and resilience to help them navigate the ever-changing pathways they will face. Students need teachers who are skilled in career guidance to support them in understanding their possible futures.”
According to the report, Ontario has introduced multiple policies in the last few years that focus on building students’ capacity to make plans and understand possible career paths. But the report says that the multiple strategies and initiatives lack coherence and often have overlapping goals.
“The government has made a commitment to ensuring that Ontario’s future workforce – our children – are prepared for lives that will have multiple career paths. But the findings in this report show that schools are struggling to implement the strategies, and that many students are missing out. While we laud the province for its ambition, we are concerned that schools are suffering from a certain sense of ‘initiative overload.’ It’s time to rationalize programs, and to make sure we have the staff and infrastructure to support them.”
Annie Kidder, Executive Director, People for Education
Among the recommendations in the report:
- Use the Creating Pathways policy, portfolios, and professional development as an anchor for other strategies such as the province’s upcoming Well-being Strategy, the Renewed Math Strategy, and the recommendations from Ontario’s Highly Skilled Workforce Expert Panel.
- Link Ontario’s compulsory 40 hours of community involvement for high school students more closely to explorations of career pathways.
- Develop consistent language and goals to link the Creating Pathways portfolios to Ontario report cards.
- Set broader goals for Ontario’s education system – beyond math, reading and writing – to ensure students are acquiring essential skills and competencies demanded by the rapidly changing job market, the knowledge economy, and the increasingly complex global reality.
- Make changes to the funding formula to ensure that students from grade 7 to 12 have adequate access to guidance counsellors.
- Clarify the role of both elementary and secondary school guidance counsellors in a way that recognizes both the breadth of their responsibilities and their relative scarcity in Ontario’s K-12 schools.